We Won!

SB 1027 Is Unconstitutional: The Ballot Belongs TO THE PEOPLE!

Here’s What That Means and Why the Fight Isn’t Over.

Last year, we told you a lawsuit over Senate Bill 1027 could decide whether Oklahoma voters keep their century-old right to shape our laws directly.

Today, we have the answer because this morning, the Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled that SB 1027 is unconstitutional and void in its entirety.

Not part of it. All of it.

The Court started where we have started from day one, with the first words of our state constitution.

“All political power is inherent in the people.”

The Court struck down every major piece of SB 1027:

  • The county signature caps. The law limited how many signatures could count from any one county. The Court found the caps violate Oklahomans’ First Amendment rights and the Oklahoma Constitution.
  • The new rules on petition summaries. The law added new requirements for the “gist,” the short summary at the top of every petition, and let the Secretary of State remove any gist the office decided didn’t comply. The Court found those requirements unconstitutional.
  • The circulator rules. The law required anyone carrying a petition to be a registered Oklahoma voter. The U.S. Supreme Court struck down the same requirement in Colorado decades ago. Ours fell too.
  • The funding and reporting rules. The law banned incentive-based pay for circulators, banned out-of-state contributions and piled on new disclosure and reporting requirements.

The Court struck them all.

SB 1027 included a clause meant to keep the rest of the law alive if parts of it fell. The Court found that what was left couldn’t stand on its own. So the whole law is void. The petition laws that existed before SB 1027 are back in full force.

What SB 1027 would have meant for you

Numbers like these can feel abstract, so here’s one county.

Harmon County has 1,378 registered voters. Under SB 1027, only 75 of them could have signed a statutory petition. The other 1,303 would have been turned away. They’re legal voters, and their signatures still wouldn’t count, because their county had “signed enough.” In Oklahoma and Tulsa counties, the caps would have shut out more than 800,000 registered voters.

SB 1027 was sold as a way to bring rural Oklahomans into the petition process. The Court found it did the opposite. When a campaign can collect only 75 signatures in a county, it has little reason to ever go there.

In the Court’s words:

“Never before have legal Oklahoma voters been outright prohibited from signing an initiative or referendum petition.”

The Court also saw the bigger picture. Each new rule raised the cost of using a right that belongs to all of us. Taken together, the Court found, the law’s cumulative effect was to discourage all Oklahomans from using it.

Who made this happen

This case was brought by four Oklahoma voters: Craig McVay, a retired educator from western Oklahoma; Amy Cerato; Kenneth Setter of Tulsa County; and Tony Stobbe of Edmond. They put their names on the line for every voter in this state and this victory absolutely belongs to them!

But this victory also belongs to all of us. Just like the ballot does.

Why protecting the ballot matters more than ever

It would be easy to call this the end of the story, but itt isn’t.

The decision was 5–4. One vote kept the petition in the hands of the people. The state can still ask the Court to reconsider. And the next legislative session is only months away.

SB 1027 wasn’t the first attempt to take this power away, and it won’t be the last. Every time Oklahomans use the ballot to do what lawmakers won’t, someone at the Capitol tries to make sure it can’t happen again.

But we are hopeful! When This Land spent this year listening to Oklahomans, voters across the political spectrum told us the same thing: when the people decide, politicians should respect it. Strong Republicans said it as loudly as anyone.

One man put it plainly:

“The people voted. Respect it.”

That isn’t a partisan value. It’s an Oklahoma value.

We’ll keep watching this case through the rehearing window. We’ll track every bill filed next session that touches your right to petition, and we’ll tell you about it before it moves and let you know how you can help protect the ballot.

The question before the Court was simple: who holds the final say over Oklahoma’s ballot, the voters or the politicians? Today the answer is the voters.

Let’s keep it that way.

November 10, 2026

Related posts

Oklahoma Economist, Steven C. Agee, Ph.D., Supports Tying Minimum Wage to CPI

June 11, 2026

Beyond the After-School Job: The Real Faces of Oklahoma’s Low-Wage Workforce

June 10, 2026

Stay Updated

Join us to learn more about how we develop effective messages to help nonpartisan groups, community leaders, advocates, and policymakers promote common sense Oklahoma values year-round.